Objectives:
The student will be able to:
-
Present, in collaboration with other students, a portfolio of materials that support historians' conclusion that the encounter between Europeans and Indians were processes viewed and experienced quite differently by the two groups.
-
Use the historians' conclusion from Objective one to develop a scenario that might explain the demise of the Roanoke colony from both European and Indian perspectives.
Suggested lesson/activities:
-
Using the motion picture "Dances with Wolves" as the source of data, in a brief discussion, derive examples of Indians' and European Americans' differing perspectives about their encounters. The teacher should record the perspective in a two-column board exhibit.
-
Using the same interest groups formed in Lesson One, have students proceed as follows:
-
Design the major elements of a portfolio that will display evidence of Indians' and European Americans' views of the process of contact and the experiences that emerged from their various encounters.
-
Assign tasks to each group member related to the elements of the portfolio.
-
Develop a set of criteria to evaluate the validity of the material as evidence of the actual processes and experiences of contact and encounter between Indians and Europeans.
-
Each member performs the assigned task.
-
The groups collectively evaluate the members' materials and select the most powerful evidence to include in their portfolios.
-
The groups present the portfolio in some way to the class.
-
Students are to read a published synopsis of the Roanoke colony's founding and disappearance in 1584.
-
Using the Roanoke reading and the findings presented in the groups' portfolio, create an Indian explanation and an English explanation of why the colony vanished.