CROSSROADS BIBLIOGRAPHICAL ESSAY


Essay Contents
Introduction: General/Thematic Studies
I. Bibliographical Essay: Essay I
II. Bibliographical Essay: Essay II
III. Bibliographical Essay: Essay III
IV. Bibliographical Essay: Essay IV
V. Bibliographical Essay: Essay V
VI. Bibliographical Essay: Essay VI
VII. Bibliographical Essay: Essay VII
VIII. Bibliographical Essay: Essay VII
IX. Bibliographical Essay: Essay IX
X. Bibliographical Essay: Essay X
XI. Bibliographical Essay: Essay XI
XII. Bibliographical Essay: Essay XII


American history has spawned a vast literature; books and scholarly and popular journals cover geographic, ecological, ethnic, racial, demographic, political, constitutional, legal, social, economic, religious, cultural, intellectual, scientific, technological, and even sexual history. This Bibliographic Essay presents the most authoritative and accessible thematic treatments of American history and scholarship for each period. Paperbacks are indicated by an asterisk.

The following valuable general or thematic studies span the whole of American history:


ESSAY I
Another valuable resource, on a somewhat more scholarly level, is the work of Professor James Axtell of the College of William and Mary, who is one of the nation's leading scholars in a new discipline, "ethnohistory," combining history, anthropology, and ethnology. Axtell's most accessible books are his collections of essays:

A fine book on one Indian people's legal system, unfortunately out of print, is

-- examines the first contacts between the Cherokee and English explorers and settlers, closely interpreting the English accounts to understand Cherokee ideas about law.

Teachers should be aware of two useful and responsible series of books for young-adult readers -- "Indians of North America," published by Chelsea House, and "The First Americans," published by Facts on File.

The controversy about the Indians as "forgotten founders" reached the mainstream public in


ESSAY II
As for Essay II, the essays of James Axtell are an invaluable resource:

The European and the Indian also contains a valuable long essay that summarizes Axtell's major work on the ethnohistory of North America, juxtaposing the English, French, and Indians. Axtell has published only the first of three projected volumes:

Also indispensable is

the single best book for the general reader on Christopher Columbus, on the history that he made, on the historiographical controversies surrounding him, and on his posthumous reputation and significance. (Axtell, in Beyond 1492, provides an excellent overview of most of the recent work on Columbus.) On Columbus, see also

and On exploration,

an abridgment of

and As Wilford points out, Morison is partial to his explorers as sailors; while there is no better writer on the challenges facing sailors and navigators in this period, he minimizes the deleterious consequences of their arrivals. For an excellent modern edition of the most impassioned contemporary indictment of the damage done to the Americas by the Spanish, see See also an excellent anthology of Enlightenment writings indicting the European colonization of the Americas:

The two best syntheses of American colonial history, which include the voyages of English, French, and Dutch explorers and early efforts to found colonies, are

and See also
ESSAY III
Again, the best syntheses of American colonial history are

and A superb brief bibliography is

The William and Mary Quarterly (3d ser., 1944--) is the best scholarly periodical in the field.

Colonial history is the biggest "growth" field in American history. It has a myriad of specialties -- religious, political, cultural, legal, social, women, ethnic, immigration, economic, literary, constitutional. Of special note are the following, presented in no particular order:

should not be overlooked (although Boorstin deliberately slights the intellectual history of the colonies, emphasizing the colonists' pragmatism).

is a wonderful book that explores issues of colonial social, political, family, ethnic, and racial history with a minimum of jargon and a wealth of superb pictures.


ESSAY IV
The era of the Revolutionary generation has spawned an extraordinarily rich and impressive scholarly literature -- both editions of primary sources and monographs:

is an accessible synthesis; its endnotes provide a useful bibliography of the literature on the Revolution through 1986, supplemented by

is an authoritative reference work.

is a fine documentary history woven from the speeches and writings of those who took part in the Revolution.

and

are especially valuable.

-- an authoritative and accessible history of the Confederation and the making of the Constitution.

The debate over the Constitution generated an extraordinarily rich political literature, and in turn historians have produced a remarkable range of editions and anthologies for one another and for classroom use:

is based on the superlative Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution, planned by Merrill Jensen and edited by John P. Kaminski, Gaspare J. Saladino, Richard Leffler, and Charles Schoenleber (11 vols. of 20 projected; Madison, Wis.: State Historical Society of Wisconsin, 1976--). One-volume selections include

and

and

A new study that combines local history, frontier history, political history, and literary analysis is

other works in this important genre of frontier political history include

and

and


ESSAY V
The two best modern syntheses of the Jacksonian era are

and

is a pathbreaking study that in turn has come under extensive criticism for the author's tendency to view Jackson and his contemporaries as direct ideological and political ancestors of the friends and foes of Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal. The first valuable corrective is

See also the fine collection of essays:

The leading biography of Jackson is

an abridgment of his three-volume biography (New York: Harper & Row, 1977-1984). See also

and


ESSAY VI
There are literally thousands of books on the Civil War and Reconstruction, including a flood of reprints stimulated by the success of Ken Burns's documentary and Geoffrey Ward's companion volume. The guidelines for the following sampling are accessibility and availability.

is a fine companion volume to the television documentary and can stand alone; the documentary is excellent on the experience of the war and its military history, less good on the causes of the war, first-rate on the political and cultural legacy of the war.

and

are excellent single-volume histories with fine bibliographies. Classic treatments in several volumes are

which leans slightly to the Confederacy, and

which leans slightly to the Union;Foote is more readable and accessible, while Nevins is more academic in treatment and documentation.

a fine documentary history of the war by participants, should be supplemented by

a superb documentary history of the slaves and their struggles for freedom.

is a great, ironic essay on the consequences of the war and its effects on the national and regional characters.

analyzes the relationships between ideas about war and American thought.

is an excellent abridgment of

his Pulitzer Prize-winning history of Dred Scott v. Sandford.

is a valuable study that revolutionized historians' understanding of the Johnson impeachment.

Abraham Lincoln is the central political, governmental, and symbolic figure of this period.

is the best introduction to Lincoln for anyone over the age of ten.

is the best short selection of Lincoln's speeches and letters, with a fine introduction. The best modern edition is

which Delbanco acknowledges; Vintage has published a one-volume paperback selection, with a suspect introduction by Gore Vidal. The two-volume Fehrenbacher edition contains the complete text of the Lincoln-Douglas debates; see also the convenient modern edition by

which surveys virtually all the leading modern work on Lincoln with excellent commentaries;

is the best book ever written about Lincoln's greatest and most famous speech.

is probably the best biography to date;

is the best study of its subject. Other fine books on Lincoln include

and and

deserve special mention for scholarly breadth and rigor and for graceful, accessible writing. The most recent concise biography is

See also

a Pulitzer Prize-winning history of its subject. There are at least two other full-length lives of Lincoln in preparation. (Andrew Delbanco praised *Philip Kunhardt et al., Lincoln [New York: Knopf, 1992] highly in his review for The New York Times Book Review. The documentary it accompanied was sloppy, confusing, and portentous.) See also the fine study by

On the assassination of Lincoln, see the confusingly titled books by

and

Turner's book, the best analysis of the events of the assassination, is surprisingly thin on public opinion; Hanchett's book is actually an entertaining, though diffuse, debunking of conspiracy theories past and present.

and and

are volumes from the authoritative and accessible New American Nation series edited by Henry Steele Commager and Richard B. Morris.

is one of the greatest American historical novel (though some readers still prefer

which emphasizes the anonymous experience of war rather than the experience of the Civil War). Shaara's only rival is

a brilliant, deeply moving account of the battle through the imagined testimonies of several witnesses at key points in the Shiloh campaign.

is an excellent novel on Gettysburg for middle-school students.


ESSAY VII
Standard works on various aspects of the period include

and ranks with Tocqueville's Democracy in America as a sensitive exploration of the United States.

is a good treatment of the interplay between technology and society since the 1870s. On labor, see

For a challenging New Left perspective, see

Specialized studies include

On immigration, see

and

deals with Jewish immigration. On education, see


ESSAY VIII
The most recent synthesis, especially notable for its attempts to integrate "new" and "old" history, is

seeks to achieve the same goals, but with less success. Standard older works include

(Progressives as backward-looking middle-class professionals concerned to preserve their status and their understanding of the world against the forces of economic and social change);

(challenges Hofstadter, asserting that Progressives were forward-looking group who sought to direct the future development of American life);

and the older but still useful

is the leading New Left interpretation.

Excellent political studies include

and Despite these volumes' titles, which would suggest a largely biographical approach, they are actually comprehensive and valuable historical syntheses.


ESSAY IX
continues to be useful for this period. Two older stand-bys that are still exciting and useful, and accessible to secondary-school and high-school students, are

and

the first book covers the 1920s and the second discusses the 1930s. See also

On prohibition, see, above all,

is an excellent discussion of the 1929 stock-market crash as an economic phenomenon.

is an equally fine treatment by an historian; see also


ESSAY X
Yet again, see After three decades,

is still perhaps the finest single-volume treatment of its subject; see also

look also for Leuchtenberg's forthcoming studies -- a collection of essays on the Supreme Court in the Age of Roosevelt and a two-volume study of the Court-packing crisis of 1937 (both from Oxford University Press).

and Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., has published three volumes of

he is at work on a fourth volume.

continues to be relevant in this period.

is still a vivid account of the 1930s.

See also

On America in the war years, see

and On the atomic bomb, see


ESSAY XI


is an excellent narrative history of the period from the end of the Second World War to the resignation of Richard Nixon; because Hodgson is a veteran British journalist, he offers a refreshing perspective on American history. Michael S. Sherry's forthocming study of the same period -- to be published in October 1995 by Yale University Press -- has already received extensive and respectful attention. See also:

a useful and entertaining narrative history, modeled on the books of Frederick Lewis Allen, covering the period 1932-1972;

an angry, passionate, and for those reasons useful history of the various movements that made the Sixties what they were; and

The veteran journalist Theodore H. White wrote a remarkable series of books (many of them classics of journalism and commentary) of great value for any student of this period:

Notable biographies include:

At least two biographies of Truman -- by Robert Ferrell and Alonzo Hamby, both specialists in the period -- are in press; and Dallek is working to complete the second volume of his life of Johnson.

On the civil rights movement:

the first of two projected volumes on Martin Luther King, Jr., and the civil rights movement;

On domestic policies such as the War on Poverty, see

On the Cold War, see

On Vietnam, see, among the hundreds of books,

On Watergate, see

and

See also

On other important issues, see

an epic comparative study of the American and Japanese automobile industries that provides a valuable perspective on the economic, cultural, and political histories of both nations;

a sprawling history of modern American journalism;

a superb history of Boston's response to federal courts' orders to use compulsory school busing to effect school integration;

a fine memoir of how "old South" politics met "new South" realities.


ESSAY XII
The following books provide a sobering view of the workings of the modern political process:

and

The following books provide an equally sobering view of the "culture wars":

Most other books on the "culture wars," multiculturalism, and political correctness add little to these three save shrillness -- see, e.g.,

and

Other excellent books on modern American life include:

The best of the books produced by the end of the Cold War include

On the Carter years,

is skilled and thoughtful.

On the Reagan years,

the best biography, focuses on the Presidency;

provides intellectual background and context. See also

and

and

are self-justifying and uninformative, as are virtually all other memoirs by figures in both parties. The "official" biography by Reagan biographer Edmund Morris has not yet appeared.

It is too soon for books on the Bush years to reach beyond the level of journalism; see, e.g.,

is a useful history of the Iran-contra affairs, but see

for an analysis that takes more seriously than Draper does the threat the "secret government" posed to the American constitutional system. See also the excellent study by

and

The Clinton years have not generated any books that approach the solidity or reliability of history -- only journalistic accounts such as

and

Woodward is already at work on another book on the Clinton presidency and the Republicans' struggle to supplant him, to appear in the summer of 1996.