Lesson Plan #:AELP-GOV0051


Who Gets the Job?

An Educator's Reference Desk Lesson Plan


Submitted by: Jeanette Jackson
School or Affiliation: Caldwell High School, Caldwell, Idaho
Endorsed by: These lesson plans are the result of the work of the teachers who have attended the Columbia Education Center's Summer Workshop. CEC is a consortium of teacher from 14 western states dedicated to improving the quality of education in the rural, western, United States, and particularly the quality of math and science Education. CEC uses Big Sky Telegraph as the hub of their telecommunications network that allows the participating teachers to stay in contact with their trainers and peers that they have met at the Workshops.

Date: May 1994


Grade Level(s): 9, 10, 11, 12

Subject(s):

Overview: While the federal bureaucracy is one of the least understood aspects of U.S. Government, it affects the American people most directly. Few Americans give any thought as to how the heads of this huge bureaucracy, the Cabinet, are chosen.

Purpose: The purpose of this lesson is for students to understand that even though Senate approval is needed for presidential Cabinet appointments, there are no qualifications or standards set for each position.

Objectives: Students will complete the following as a result of this lesson:

  1. Match Cabinet positions with current secretaries.
  2. Evaluate the qualifications of each secretary with respect to his/her position.
  3. Develop a set of qualifications for two Cabinet positions.

Resources/Materials: The biographical sketches do not need to be current in order to fulfill the purpose of this lesson. However, as Cabinet secretaries change or when a new administration begins, teachers may want to update the sketches. Keeping the sketches current also makes the lesson more relevant to students as they study current news. Biographical information on the Cabinet can be obtained from Congressional Research Service, The Library of Congress, Washington D.C., 20540. Your Senator or Congressman may be helpful in getting this information from CRS quickly.

Activities and Procedures:

  1. Divide the class into small groups of 3 - 4 students.

  2. Distribute the material titled "Who Gets the Job". Read the introduction out loud and answer any questions students may have.

  3. Allow the groups 15 - 20 minutes to complete the activity.

  4. Have each group announce its choice of Cabinet position for each biographical sketch. Group members must justify their choices. After each biographical sketch has been discussed, tell them the correct position and the name of the current secretary.

Tying It All Together: After discussing each biographical sketch, have the students list common characteristics found in the members of the Cabinet. These qualities should be listed on the chalkboard. Next, assign each group 2 or 3 Cabinet posts and have them develop a specific set of qualifications for the head of each department. This activity could be turned in as a graded assignment.


Who Gets the Job?

Introduction: We have been studying the presidency and the executive departments, specifically the role of the Cabinet. You have read a description of what each Cabinet department does. Keep this in mind as you read the biographical sketches below. The sketches give some facts about the current members of the Cabinet under President George Bush. The persons are not identified by name in the sketches. As you read each sketch, decide which executive department each person would be best qualified to head.

Cabinet Positions:
Sec. of State Sec. of Labor
Sec. of the Treasury Sec. of Health and Human Services
Sec. of Defense Sec. of Housing and Urban Development
Attorney General Sec. of Transportation
Sec. of the Interior Sec. of Energy
Sec. of Agriculture Sec. of Education
Sec. of Commerce Sec. of Veterans Affairs


Individual One - ___________ Individual Three - ___________
Age: 52 Age: 61
Former public school teacher Campaign chairman for Pres. Bush
Served in Illinois House of Representatives Served in Marines
Served in Illinois Senate Trustee for Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars
Served in Congress from Illinois (10 yrs.) White House Chief of Staff under Reagan
National co-chairman for Bush-Quayle Presidential campaign Lawyer
Undersecretary for Dept. of Commerce
Secretary of Treasury under Reagan
From Texas

Individual Two - ___________ Individual Four - ____________
Age: 51 Age: 55
Lawyer Owner of taxi company
Former Governor of Tennessee (8 yrs.) Illinois State legislator
Legal assistant to Sen. Howard Baker Served in Congress from Illinois (18 yrs.)
Chairman of Republican Research Committee
Member of President's Task Force on Federalism Served on House Agriculture Committee
Chairman of National Governors Assoc.

Individual Five - ____________ Individual Ten - ____________
Age: 64 Age: 61
Independent Texas oil and gas producer M.B.A. Harvard University
Chief Executive officer and chairman of Mosbacher Energy Co. U.S. Senator from New Jersey
Chairman of Nat'l Petroleum Council Chairman and chief executive officer of an investment and securities firm
National finance chairman for Bush for President Served in MX missile development options panel
Director New York Life Ins. Co. Served on Central America Study Commission
Co-chairman of Republican National Finance Committee Chairman of President's Commission on Executive, Legislative, and Judicial Salaries

Individual Six - ___________ Individual Eleven - __________
Age: 50 Age: 59
Congressman from Wyoming (10 yrs.) Lawyer
Aide to Governor of Wisconsin U.S. Attorney for Pennsylvania
Deputy Assistant to Pres. Ford Governor of Penn. (8 yrs.)
Assistant Director of Cost of Living Council Asst. Atty. General for Dept. of Justice
Republican leader in House of Representatives Director of Institute of Politics, JFK School of Government, Harvard Univ.

Individual Seven - ___________ Individual Twelve- ___________
Age: 65 Age: 58
Served in Illinois legislature Physician
Congressman from Illinois (24 yrs.) and under-secretary in Dept. of State Associate Professor of Medicine, Boston Counselor University (6 yrs.)
Delegate to the U.N. General Assembly Dean of School of Medicine, Morehouse College (14 yrs.)

Individual Eight - __________ Individual Thirteen- ________
Age: 56 Age: 63
Special Asst. to governor of Calif. Insurance and real estate businessman
Congressman from New York (18 yrs.) Served on President's National Commission on Space
Professional football player (13 yrs.) Congressman from New Mexico (20 yrs.)
Public relations officer for bank Chairman of House Science, Space, and Technology Committee
Ran for Republican nomination for Pres.1987 - 1988
Served on President's Council on Physical Fitness and Sports.

Individual Nine - __________ Individual Fourteen- _________
Age: 64 Age: 53
U.S. Naval Academy graduate Lawyer
Chairman of Presidential Commission on the HIV (AIDS) Epidemic Salesman for IBM
Admiral in U. S. Navy Asst. U.S. Attorney for Illinois
Commander in Chief of U.S. Pacific Fleet U.S. Attorney for Illinois
Served on advisory boards in education and energy fields Chairman of Regional Transportation Authority for Illinois
Served in U.S. Army
Vice Chairman of the President's Commission on Organized Crime
Illinois Campaign Director for Bush


Answers for "Who Gets the Job?"

Individual One - Secretary of Labor - Lynn Martin
Individual Two - Secretary of Education - Lamar Alexander
Individual Three - Secretary of State - James A. Baker, III
Individual Four - Secretary of Agriculture - Edward Madigan
Individual Five - Secretary of Commerce - Robert Mosbacher
Individual Six - Secretary of Defense - Dick Cheney
Individual Seven - Secretary of Veterans Affairs - Edward Derwinski
Individual Eight - Secretary of Housing and Urban Development - Jack Kemp
Individual Nine - Secretary of Energy - James D. Watkins
Individual Ten - Secretary of the Treasury - Nicholas Brady
Individual Eleven - Attorney General - Richard Thornburgh
Individual Twelve - Secretary of Health and Human Services - Louis Sullivan
Individual Thirteen - Secretary of the Interior - Manuel Lujan, Jr.
Individual Fourteen - Secretary of Transportation - Samuel Skinner